America’s favorite pastime is taking center stage in a new production at the Goodman Theatre.

“Toni Stone” is the story of the first woman to play in baseball’s Negro Leagues. Stone was rejected by the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League due to her race, so she instead joined an all-male baseball team, the Indianapolis Clowns, to play second base.

“I think it’s of the utmost importance to play iconic characters who we have never heard of,” said actress Tracey Bonner, who plays Stone. “I didn’t, and I played baseball from 5-12 and softball, and I had never heard of this iconic woman.”

Bonner said of the play: “What you’ll learn are some of the obstacles she faced — part of that her mother not being supportive. She wanted to do traditional mother things. She was proficient in a lot of things and didn’t want to limit herself. It follows her journey in an all-male sport, some of the things she had to do to fit in and some of the things she had to comprise herself to be in this sport.” 

Playwright Lydia Diamond said one of the elements she wanted to highlight was that despite Stone’s challenges, she achieved her goals.

“The story I’m telling is about Toni Stone,” Diamond said. “Some things she encountered were horrible things. It made not what White people have done to us the story — it was important to me that that not be the story.”

Diamond continued: “A thing I don’t see on stage as much as I’d like — [I] wanted to see a group of men hold up a Black woman and tell her story. So the men play different characters. The men play women. Someone plays her mother. They play White and Black people, it’s exciting. … I wanted to see Toni Stone on the stage by herself the way she would be. It’s compelling to me, the way a woman pushes her way into a world that didn’t want her and is so successful. That’s part of the story of her story.”

Set in the 1950s, the play aims to celebrate Stone’s home runs, despite the racist and sexist barriers. Bonner said the show is a celebration of who Toni was, not necessarily what she did.

“She says it in the play: ‘You can do anything if you work real hard.’ Believe in yourself, and fight for what you believe in and who you want you be — I think that is the biggest takeaway,” Bonner said. “Always fight for who you are and know that you are enough.”

“Toni Stone” runs at the Goodman Theatre through Feb. 26.

Follow Angel Idowu on Twitter: @angelidowu3

Angel Idowu is the JCS Fund of the DuPage Foundation Arts Correspondent.