Lawmakers Want to Limit Police Use of Stingray Cellphone Trackers

Law enforcement agencies on Thursday met with Illinois lawmakers about legislation that would limit the use of new technology that tracks cell phone use.

The device, called a Stingray, has purportedly been used for surveillance by the Chicago Police Department during protests and rallies, but the department has been secretive about exactly how extensively its used. It has raised questions about invasion of privacy that civil libertarians and lawmakers are trying to answer.

Thanks to our sponsors:

View all sponsors

“Stingrays” are small devices that mimic cellphone towers. They are typically carried in police vehicles that have antenna that attract every cellphone signal in the area. 

“The towers are able to capture the serial information and identify every phone that is in the area,” said Ed Yohnka of the ACLU of Illinois. “So even if the police are looking for a certain phone or tracking an individual, in the course of an investigation, they sweep up all of the identifying information about everyone who is in that particular area.”

Yohnka says that law enforcement agencies primarily use Stingrays as tracking devices, but he’s concerned that they are capable of doing much more.

“It’s able to capture the serial number, it’s now able to capture the content of what’s on the phone, who the phone has called, what numbers have been dialed, what numbers are stored, what websites have been visited, text messages sent and received, and it can actually send things to the smart phone. So one of the new tools of this technology is to send a signal that drains the battery, or blocks the phone, or places malware on the phone so that the government or a law enforcement agency can control the phone,” Yohnka said.

  • Harris Kingfish

    Harris Kingfish

  • Harris Stingray II

    Harris Stingray II

  • Harris Stingray

    Harris Stingray

Legislation filed by State Sen. Daniel Biss and State Rep. Ann Williams has bipartisan support and would prohibit law enforcement agencies from using Stingrays for any purpose other than tracking the target of an investigation. It would also require them to ignore any information retrieved from other nearby cell phone users.

“We believe this use has to be carefully regulated because it’s incredibly powerful and incredibly dangerous,” said Biss. “One, get a court order from a judge based on probable cause. Two, delete an extraneous information so that if you just happen to be in an area where someone is being targeted, they can’t just spy on you and keep your information.”

A Cook County judge last month ordered the city to turn over to her any documents related to the use of Stingrays by the police department in response to a Freedom of Information lawsuit filed by activist Freddy Martinez.

Martinez’s attorney, Matt Topic, says he thinks the proposed legislation will curb what he sees are abuses by the use of Stingrays, but says they should be eliminated entirely.

“You’ve already violated the Fourth Amendment once you collect and store cell phone information from someone you don’t have a court order to search,” Topic said. “There’s no way under the Fourth Amendment a Stingray could ever be used.”

Follow Paris Schutz on Twitter: [email protected]

Thanks to our sponsors:

View all sponsors

Thanks to our sponsors:

View all sponsors