Chicago City Council Orders Independent Review of Finances as Scrutiny Intensifies

Mayor Brandon Johnson listens on during a Nov. 18, 2026, special City Council meeting. (Victor Hilitski / WTTW News) Mayor Brandon Johnson listens on during a Nov. 18, 2026, special City Council meeting. (Victor Hilitski / WTTW News)

This report was co-published with ProPublica. Sign up for Dispatches, a ProPublica newsletter that spotlights wrongdoing around the country, to receive our stories in your inbox every week. Sign up for the Daily Chicagoan from WTTW News, a newsletter that explores the backstory of the city’s biggest issues.


The debate over the city of Chicago’s financial struggles — out in the open as never before — took a new turn on Wednesday as the City Council added to the scrutiny.

The Chicago City Council voted 45-5 in a special meeting to give a leading alderperson the authority to hire an outside firm for an independent review of the city’s finances. 

Thanks to our sponsors:

View all sponsors

Alds. William Hall (4th Ward), David Moore (18th Ward), Jason Ervin (28th Ward), Rossana Rodriguez Sanchez and Byron Sigcho-Lopez (25th Ward) voted against the measure.

It’s unclear if an audit would be complete in time for the City Council to consider its findings before the Dec. 29 deadline mandated by state law to pass a 2027 budget in what promises to be contentious negotiations with Mayor Brandon Johnson.

The intense debate over the city’s financial future comes in the wake of a package of stories published Monday by WTTW News and ProPublica that examined how a $55 billion debt burden, decades in the making, was hampering efforts to service Chicagoans and how the Johnson administration was turning to more borrowing to plug holes, such as large police settlements.

Ald. Pat Dowell (3rd Ward), had called for the independent review after former Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch abruptly resigned Friday over what she has described as a political environment that forced her to downplay certain facts about the city’s financial situation. Gabrysch argued that her integrity would be compromised if she stayed on.

Ald. Pat Dowell (3rd Ward) speaks during the Nov. 18, 2026, Chicago City Council meeting. (Victor Hilitski / WTTW News)Ald. Pat Dowell (3rd Ward) speaks during the Nov. 18, 2026, Chicago City Council meeting. (Victor Hilitski / WTTW News)

Just as Gabrysch had once been a trusted part of Johnson’s team, Dowell was once thought to be a mayoral ally. Johnson tapped Dowell, who endorsed him during the 2023 mayoral election, to lead the City Council’s Finance Committee soon after he took office. But since then Dowell has proven to be a thorn in the mayor’s side, refusing to support his proposal to impose a $25 per month per employee tax on most firms that have more than 125 employees and hike the city’s personal property lease tax.

The ordinance gives Dowell the authority to spend whatever is necessary to hire a firm — or firms — “to determine whether any material or intentional misstatements of the city’s financial condition to investors, the City Council and the public have been made in any public document, presentation, offering or financial reporting within the prior three years.”

The firm, of firms, hired to conduct the review will have unfettered access to all city documents and records, and all city officials must cooperate with the probe, according to the ordinance. 

“We must ensure that our math is correct,” Dowell said, vowing to act quickly. “The discrepancies over the past few weeks have been particularly disturbing to me. As mother used to say, where there’s smoke, there’s fire.”

Johnson said he welcomed the review and will not veto the ordinance.

Ervin, who is one of the mayor’s closest allies, called the independent review a “waste of taxpayer money and taxpayer resources,” since the city’s certified annual audits have found nothing of concern.

Ervin accused Gabyrsch of making a $75 million payment to the city’s pension funds without authority. Gabyrsch has said she did nothing wrong.

“The woman spent $75 million she didn’t have any business doing at the time she did, and now she wants to throw everybody under the bus for that,” Ervin said. “And now we got to spend a million or some dollars for it? Makes no sense. This is more theater.”

But Ald. Andre Vasquez (40th Ward), said the City Council must act to restore the public’s trust in the city’s finances, which he said had been badly shaken by Gabyrsch’s resignation.

“I want every single email, every single communication, because we don’t know what’s happening on the fifth floor,” Vasquez said, referring to the location of the mayor’s office.

Justin Marlowe, a professor at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy and the director of the Center for Municipal Finance, said he wasn’t sure an audit was warranted. But he noted that the inability of the council and the mayor to agree on a budget plan along with the demand for an audit will not sit well with credit rating agencies. 

“The way cities make their budgets matter,” Marlowe said. “It matters that for the third year in a row that there are disagreements over basic facts.”

An audit so close to the deadline for the budget will not reassure analysts that all is well with Chicago’s finances, Marlowe said. “Investors don’t like uncertainty,” Marlowe said. “And this is creating a lot of uncertainty.”

In response to the WTTW News and ProPublica report on the city’s debt, Ald. Matt Martin (47th Ward) said Wednesday that the analysis was “sobering” and he is questioning some of Johnson’s borrowing strategies.

The city’s financial peril had been pushed to the back burner by a series of crises that have confronted the city in the past five years: the COVID-19 pandemic, the influx of migrants to Chicago from the southern border and the aggressive immigration raids that swept the city in fall 2025, said Martin said, who is particularly concerned that it would cost the city $190 million to borrow $350 million in 2027, as proposed by the mayor.

“That’s what’s really crowding out our ability to spend on other things we need to do as a city,” Martin said.

Over the years, Chicago alderpeople have generally acquiesced to mayoral directives on finances. But that has changed under Johnson, in part due to his preference for a head tax but also because of the growing realization that the city’s finances have been undermined by a series of decisions from previous mayors. 

Similarly, top administration officials generally choose to leave City Hall either quietly or with words of praise for the current mayor. That’s not how Gabrysch handled her exit.

The statement she released Friday made it clear she had severe doubts about the way Johnson was portraying the city’s debt problem. And she reiterated those concerns in a commentary in the Chicago Tribune over the weekend that also laid out her suggestions for how the city can more responsibly handle its budgeting (for example, “Don’t borrow to pay everyday bills, even if we’ve done so in the past”).

Then, in a brief interview with the Chicago Sun-Times on Monday, she said she supported calls for a financial audit. Gabrysch declined to speak on the record with WTTW News.

“If this makes it easier for residents to see that Chicago actually is in a fairly dire fiscal situation where hard decisions … and shared sacrifices have to be made, that can be helpful,’’ Gabrysch said. “Shining some light on the city’s finances — whether or not they discover wrongdoing, but rather showing the nuances of how dire some things have become — could be worthwhile.’’

Chicago’s credit rating has been plummeting, adding to the cost of borrowing. Gabrysch had been hired from Fitch Ratings, a credit agency, with an eye toward shoring up the city’s reputation. But she left the city after only three months.

In the aftermath of Gabrysch’s departure, Johnson’s administration has sought to portray her as someone who fell short in her duties and mismanaged a major transfer of funds — characterizations she has disputed.

The Chicago City Council meets on Nov. 18, 2026. (Victor Hilitski / WTTW News)The Chicago City Council meets on Nov. 18, 2026. (Victor Hilitski / WTTW News)

While Johnson’s critics on the City Council have seized on Gabrysch’s statements as evidence that the mayor and his team may have pressured Gabrysch to present a false picture of the city’s finances, Johnson dismissed the conflict that led to her resignation as a “technical dispute.”

When he unveiled his budget, Johnson and administration officials said 76% of the budget gap would be closed with so-called “structural fixes” — long-term or permanent solutions — that would bring expenses in line with revenues. That could help the city avoid another credit downgrade. 

But Gabrysch told the City Council on Oct. 26 that the decision to borrow $481 million to cover the cost of resolving police misconduct lawsuits in 2027 and 2028 changed that calculation, reducing the amount the gap closed with revenue the city can count on in future years to just 56%.

As recently as September, Johnson told reporters the city would not borrow to cover those costs. 

The controversy surrounding Gabrysch and Johnson’s borrowing plans has complicated already fraught negotiations over Johnson’s proposed $17.6 billion spending plan, leaving the city on the brink of another budget impasse. 

Johnson has held his ground on his proposal to impose a $25 per month per employee tax on most firms that have more than 125 employees and hike the city’s personal property lease tax. But a majority of alderpersons have ruled out voting for a budget that contains either proposal, leaving the two sides $409 million apart with just over a month until the deadline for the City Council to pass a budget.

If the City Council approves Johnson’s proposal to borrow $481 million, the city’s massive debt burden — which now tops $55 billion — is set to grow for the second straight year to cover the cost of running the city, a sign of financial distress.

That distress, Johnson has argued, is largely due to the decisions of previous administrations. “It’s no secret: Our city finds itself in a precarious financial situation due to decades of mismanagement,” Johnson said Tuesday.

Contact Heather Cherone: @HeatherCherone | (773) 569-1863 | [email protected]


Thanks to our sponsors:

View all sponsors

Thanks to our sponsors:

View all sponsors